Welcome to Mandy's Ice Cream
At Mandy's Ice Cream, located in the heart of Brownsburg, IN, we believe in creating more than just delicious treats; we craft memorable experiences. Founded by Amanda Johnson, our family-run shop prides itself on exceptional customer service and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. With an incredible variety of flavors—like the tangy lemon meringue and the delightful "Kitty Kitty Bang Bang"—and classic sundaes, there's something for everyone. Our commitment to community shines through not only in our delectable ice creams but also in our support for local initiatives. Every scoop here is a celebration of creativity, kindness, and flavor, ensuring you leave with a smile!
-
1042 E Main St, Brownsburg, IN 46112 Hotline: (317) 350-2467
Welcome to Mandy's Ice Cream, a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Brownsburg, Indiana. Located at 1042 E Main St, this charming establishment has quickly become a beloved spot for both locals and visitors seeking a sweet escape. With a diverse menu that caters to every ice cream lover's imagination, Mandy's Ice Cream stands out as a family-run business dedicated to quality, creativity, and exceptional customer service.
At Mandy's, you'll find an impressive assortment of frozen treats that caters to both traditionalists and adventurous palates. Their offerings include:
- Ice Cream Scoops: From the indulgent Triple Scoop to the charming Kiddie Scoop, every option is crafted to deliver maximum enjoyment.
- Sundaes & Splits: Dive into tantalizing creations like the Banana Royale and the whimsical Big Bulldog sundae. Each dessert is an experience, combining flavors and textures in delightful harmony.
- Shakes, Malts, Floats & Frappes: Whether you prefer a classic Old Fashioned Soda or a creamy Malts treat, there's something for every mood.
What truly sets Mandy's apart isn’t just their wide variety of flavors, but the warmth and care exuded by the team. As one patron, Megan G., beautifully expressed, the friendly staff isn't just there to scoop—I must say, they’re more like ice cream superheroes, ready to help you find that perfect flavor even on indecisive days. Similar sentiments are echoed across many reviews, mentioning how employee interactions elevate the experience from simply having ice cream to enjoying a personal connection with the community.
The ambiance at Mandy’s Ice Cream is just as inviting. With a cozy interior that features local art and ample seating, it’s the perfect spot to enjoy your scoops. You can also expect a crowd, particularly on warm evenings, which speaks volumes about its popularity. Customers rave about flavors like Kitty Kitty Bang Bang, which delightfully marries raspberry with creamy vanilla, while others can’t resist the nostalgic pull of Cotton Candy and Raspberry Rhapsody.
Moreover, the attention to detail doesn’t stop at the flavors. The owner, Amanda (or Mandy, as everyone affectionately knows her), has fostered a culture of community spirit within her shop. With flavors inspired by local tastes and special creations that keep customers coming back for more, it’s clear that Mandy's Ice Cream isn’t just about ice cream; it’s about creating lasting memories one scoop at a time.
In a world where larger chains dominate, Mandy's Ice Cream serves as a refreshing reminder of what a family-run business can achieve. From their signature Banana Split to creative sundaes, each bite invites you to savor the moment. If you’re ever in Brownsburg, take the time to experience the warmth and flavor of Mandy's Ice Cream—it’s an essential stop for anyone with a sweet tooth. You won’t be disappointed, and as many have noted, you might even find yourself going back for a reward, just like Cassidy R. As summer begins to fade, let Mandy's be the highlight of your sweet indulgences!
You ever have one of those days where you know you want ice cream, but you have absolutely no idea what kind? This was one of those days. I was an indecisive, hormonal, hot mess, and the worker behind the counter was an absolute gem. We talked through my mood, my general indecisiveness, and my very strong dislike of chocolate (yes, I know, I'm weird). When nothing on display seemed just right, she casually mentioned they had an additional flavor in the back--without the chocolate chunks. After much deliberation (and multiple reassurances that she really didn't mind scooping into the reserves), I finally went for it. Do you believe she had the audacity to apologize to me for taking "a long time" to bring me my ice cream? As if she wasn't already my hero of the day. The ice cream, the conversation, the kindness--everything was exactly what I needed. Some heroes wear capes. Others scoop ice cream.
While my husband and I were out shopping we got a craving for something sweet and decided to find a little spot that was family run. I feel like the larger corporations are taking over and the smaller family businesses need as much help as they can get. We found this little spot in Brownsburg called Mandy's ice cream which we had never tried and it was really really good. I'm not one to try the normal flavors you can buy from kroger because what's the point of that? So I went with the kitty kitty bang bang. It had vanilla, raspberry, chocolate chips, chocolate cookies, and raspberry sauce is believe. It was very good and the raspberry flavor gave it a good punch with each bite. My husband got a sprinkle cone dipped and had a double chocolate type brownie. It was really good.
Mandy's is great. I have been there a lot of times and they never have disappointed me. The ice cream is always impressing me. The boba is fantastic. The service is helpful and very nice. The building is great for a small ice cream shop.
When I say this is some of the best ice cream I've had, I am not joking. First time being here, and I love to be able to come back! I got a double scoop with cotton candy and raspberry rhapsody. It was delicious! Cotton candy had hints of bubble gum as well which was a delight. Would highly recommend them if you're ever near by and want ice cream.
Ed my and the service. Y'all r very welcoming and generous I'm gonna keep coming here everytime I need a reward
I've not been to Mandy's before and I'm so happy finally made the visit! We went on a Friday afternoon and that place was filled to the brim with happy customers eating their ice cream! Even though there was a line, the two employees handled it was grace and exceptional customer service! Bravo! Now to the yummy ice cream ! There were so many different ice cream flavors, which was wonderful! We ordered lemon meringue, mint chocolate chip, and kitty kitty (which was a cheesecake-ish flavor). We ordered junior cups (smallest size) and it was still plenty! We ate every single drop. The ice cream was creamy, full of flavor, and overall delicious!
This place is great. They have a variety of flavors and dessert dishes and even have kid cones! They have seating inside and kind staff. They also display local art.
Nothing says summer like a scoop or three of ice cream. I enjoy trying smaller local shops and was happy when i discovered this shop. It seems to be pretty popular as they were consistently busy but there was minimal wait. The employees were all pretty friendly and very helpful with providing recommendations. I had salted carmel and another salty popular scoop that were both tasty and i will be back to try some of the other flavors. The interior is fairly small but indoor dining is available and there is also a bench in front of the store to dine on while basking in the sunlight.
I loved, loved, loved this place. It is a neat little hand scooped ice cream shop located just outside of downtown Brownsburg. It is the epitome of a small business and I was glad that I was able to come there, check them out and review them. The owner, Amanda (Mandy) Johnson, was actually working the shop during my visit. She was very welcoming, friendly, up-beat, helpful and personable. She greeted me as soon as I walked in, with a handful of sample sticks. She calls her shop the Burger King of ice cream shops, where you can have it your way. She is definitely all Brownsburg, through and through and is proud of and supports her town. They also operate an ice cream truck, which you will probably see in the parking lot. There is tons of parking available in the lot that it shares with the other businesses in the strip mall that it is located. The shop is very tiddy and if you are wondering what the pictures on the back wall are about, they are part of a school project from two local elementary classes that is funded by The Brownsburg Education Foundation, They serve some signature sundaes, make your own sundaes, ice cream scoops (cone or cup), banana splits and boba teas. They have all your standard toppings to go on your ice cream like sprinkles, caramel, fudge, strawberry, peanuts, marshmallow fluff, pineapple, whipped cream, M&Ms and gummy bears to name a few. Mandy asked me what my taste were and then personally suggested ice cream samples based off my taste. I sampled (they were decent sized samples) a few of their ice creams and I was hooked. This $&%! Just Got Serious was my favorite, but I really liked all of them. The shop is pet friendly and has a decent sized dining area if you want to eat your savory treat right on the spot. After a long deliberation, I decided to go with a Banana Royal (a banana split in a cup). Of course I got it with a scoop of This $&%! Just Got Serious and I got a scoop of Coconut Almond Bliss for my second scoop. It took about 5 minutes for her to prepare and I was getting it to go. Mandy packaged it up very nice to travel. It did make it all the way home. It was very delicious. The ice cream and ingredients were fresh and had a good flavor. I almost ate the spoon. This shop is amazing, the owner is amazing, and the ice cream is amazing. I give this spot one of my highest recommendations. I enjoyed my delicious treat from this family run shop, with deep Brownsburg roots. Trust me, you will not be disappointed.